Start with the central claim, then look for the evidence, context and limits that a headline cannot contain.
Begin with the actual question
Before agreeing or disagreeing with a headline, turn it into a question. What is being claimed? Who or what does the claim concern? This helps you read for an answer rather than for confirmation of a first impression.
Look at what the article adds
Read the supporting detail. Pay attention to dates, definitions and the difference between something that happened and an interpretation of why it happened. Check whether the article explains the limits of its evidence.
Follow one important source
Choose a central statement and examine the source used to support it. Ask whether that source establishes the claim itself or something narrower. A link is useful only when the material at its destination is relevant.
Keep one question open
You do not have to reach a firm conclusion after every article. Identify what remains uncertain and what additional information would help. A more precise question can be a valuable result of reading.
Demonstration article for the TBI Journal theme. Review, expand and add appropriate sources before public launch.